Hold up. Let me get this straight - Synology is trying to make their NASs only work with their own proprietary hard drives? Do they not realize that there are boat loads of other companies out there making NASs and Hard Drives?
Who the hell is going to want to buy a Synology NAS now? Ffs, some of these companies are so delusional…
It’s one of those really myopic decisions that sink companies. But god bless em, they just keep trying lol
Short term profits reign king once again
Gotta make the imaginary money line go up somehow
Is there a reason to think all the other companies couldn’t start doing it to?
because tons and tons of potential solutions exist. At the core of this class of product is a very simple computer that costs next to nothing. FOSS software exists to accomplish the same goal and for minimal cost someone can compete with them.
Synology doesn’t really control anything. In the enterprise segment they tend to be tiny little offerings that are on the small end of SMB. Their bigger bulkier enterprise stuff is easily overshadowed by any real enterprise offering from a larger hardware company, though i’ve seen some exist even in larger orgs but it’s not because something else couldn’t have done the job.
Anyone starting fresh has to do some work to catch up but it really depends on the use case. Basic NAS/DAS functions are so trivial.
Even if the drive prices are not raised to unreasonable levels, if ever Synology decides to stop selling these drives the NAS you have purchased will become useless. Think I’ll pass.
It doesn’t become useless, it just misses out on a bunch of useful features for the drives.
Still ridiculous, of course
Well shit… I don’t even think about that.
I’m in the market for my first NAS. Synology made the choice a bit easier.
Thank you.
Fixed
Worked-around, you mean. And that hack seems temporary.
This sucks as a long time Synology customer. They really should know their audience better.
Oh well. Back to proxmox to handle everything
My switch to Unraid is feeling better every day 😀
I bought a Terramaster instead. Better hardware specs for the money and you can overwrite the OS with Linux which is way better than any stock OS.
Their website looks pretty sketchy, ngl
Sketch? Nah bro, that is exactly the kind of “This looked sick in the early 2000s and we haven’t bothered updating it since” level of design that I want to see from a hardware vendor. That’s a company that’s just sitting there quietly trucking along, making nerdy devices for nerdy people. That’s a website that was never intended to be viewed by anyone other than a 30+ year old sysadmin who owns at least one beard grooming product.
deleted by creator
Mine has an internal USB so you can open it up pretty easily and install any version of Linux you prefer. Not sure what model you bought, but I would assume you can too.
deleted by creator
That stinks. I have the F4-424 Pro and I love it.
Like you said, sketchy OS, that is probably less performant than Linux and may not get proper security updates.
but then what’s the point in buying an expensive NAS when you could just buy a pi with much more power, community support, packages, etc,
Exactly, what’s the point?
This is what I’ll replace my DS415+ with, too, once it dies. The TerraMasters are basically bog-standard Intel NUCs with a storage adapter. And there’s HDMI output and an internal USB drive which you can just replace (or overwrite) and install OMV or TrueNAS or whatever.
I switched from a HP MicroServer with TrueNAS (the BSD one) to a Synology 8-bay system because of convenience, mostly (DIY 8-bay with hot swap, low idle power and all seems hard to come by).
Hopefully it’ll last for years to come but if I ever need to replace/upgrade it it’s not gonna be another Synology with this type of extreme vendor lock-in.
So glad I went with asustor. Synology lost their god damned minds
I have an Asustor that is running Debian. It’s just a PC in a NAS enclosure so why should it not.
That’s all a NAS has ever been, just a PC that specializes in storage. “NAS” isn’t a specific product, either - it’s whatever hardware you set up to function as such. My own NAS is a 2014 Mac mini running OMV (Debian 12 based) with a 4-bay locking drive dock attached to it. Works great.
I took images of my gaming PC drives (500GB, 2TB) onto a 4TB spinner, then shoved that spinner into my NAS’s dock. With 2 minutes of point and click configuration, I can access those images from my gaming PC’s new Linux install over the network to copy whatever data I might need. Easy peasy. No Synology needed for that.
deleted by creator
This sounds like the company from Cory Doctorow’s most recent novel, Picks & Shovels
Consumer NAS devices is a lost plot point either way.
Buy a 2nd hand thinkpad or a gaming PC for basically the same price as synology tray and you’ll have not only a NAS but a full home server that’ll last you a decade and play video games as an extra.
