Commentor is not saying they should do this. They are doing this.
“The penalty is a 1-year ban from arXiv followed by the requirement that subsequent arXiv submissions must first be accepted at a reputable peer-reviewed venue,” Dietterich wrote.
arXiv has postprints, too, and it means that once a journal has accepted your work, you can prerelease before they publish.
But yes, they are effectively telling the research community to get their shit together before submitting, or pay the price.
Commentor is not saying they should do this. They are doing this.
arXiv has postprints, too, and it means that once a journal has accepted your work, you can prerelease before they publish.
But yes, they are effectively telling the research community to get their shit together before submitting, or pay the price.
Oh my bad, I interpreted the comment as saying it should be a general requirement.
Yea, I figured! Pretty heavy handed on arXiv’s part, so I’m not surprised by the interpretation. Though, I like the heavy handedness.