Fediverse Advocate

  • 3 Posts
  • 62 Comments
Joined 2 years ago
cake
Cake day: June 19th, 2023

help-circle







  • what you say is respectfully a load of shit.

    I was arguing against a UI. You told me what I said was a load of shit. I responded to it. It’s kinda clear how I thought you were trying to argue for a UI with “but nhs bad actually” which I’ve heard a lot of people say when I argue that access to free healthcare is a good reason to stay in the UK


  • Flax@feddit.uktoEurope@feddit.orgSinn Fein pushes for EU to back united Ireland
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    3
    arrow-down
    3
    ·
    edit-2
    7 days ago

    Ours N.H.S is on its knees

    And how will a United Ireland fix that, exactly?

    police are seriously underfunded

    Per capita, the PSNI has more funding than the Gardai Síochána

    Sinn Féin are the largest party in the North

    Yes, because of constant Unionist Schism. They didn’t gain any seats in the last election. Stormont has 90 MLAs. By party lines, 53 are against a United Ireland, 36 are in favour.

    The two problems you listed won’t be magically fixed by a United Ireland - if anything, they’d be made worse. So my point still stands. I wasn’t painting NI as a haven above other European countries - just that a United Ireland is a bad idea and we’re far better off under the current situation. People thought that Brexit would somehow magically fix the UK’s problems. It just made them worse. United Ireland is the same thing, if not on a worse scale.



  • I’m Northern Irish.

    This is a terrible idea. Northern Ireland is actually doing pretty well, and the standard and cost of living is lower than the Republic. The border is basically not there for British and Irish citizens. It’s just a matter of currency change and speed limit change. The EU backing a United Ireland would cause already a lot more distrust in the EU by Unionists to the point of breaking Stormont again (Keep in mind how difficult it was for Stormont to be happy with the Brexit arrangements)

    As a matter of fact, Northern Ireland is actually starting to grow. It now has an economically advantageous position that a United Ireland would destroy. It has mostly customs free access to the UK market, access to the EU single market, and now is one of the few places in the EU single market that can export to the USA with a lower tariff rate. All for the price of a what is essentially line on a map (you can’t even tell exactly where it is IRL, the border isn’t that strongly defined legally or geographically)

    Sinn Féin are disliked by both the Irish and British governments. They are the political wing of what once was the Provisional Irish Republican Army, a terrorist organisation.

    I know it doesn’t curtail ideologically to either hardline side, but the current arrangement in place is good. I live in Northern Ireland and have lower living costs and more access to social services for free than someone would have in the Republic. In some cases, better than the mainland UK. We pay less for university education than England and also don’t have charges for prescribed medicine or even water usage. Our police are well invested in and Belfast is now one of the safest cities in Europe if you don’t get involved in paramilitary feuds or drug dealing. Life here is good, and a United Ireland would jeopardize that significantly.